My thoughts on Adam Gopnik’s essay:
It seems that Gopnik has a very strong view on gun control. Although Gopnik never does talk about the other side and instead harasses the other sides faults in a somewhat bias manner, he brings up extremely valid points. The facts about other countries having more gun control laws and less gun violence is obvious, but the ones about the United States having the most gun violence is quite shocking. Most people would think that it would be higher in third-world-countries. He also uses the fact that the U.S.A is the only country to have a repeated mass murder incident and not change the law. He seems to beat on the U.S and display each and every weakness which I thought was an effective technique. It did change my view from a person who was neutral to a person who wants stricter gun control laws.
Gopnik also has an odd writing style that may persuade readers. He starts off with a morbid and pedantic story about the Virginia Tech. shooting. Talking about how the dead students won’t answer a phone call to their parents. I think this is an interesting approach on a persuasive essay, not quite a tactical approach. The depression didn’t put me in a mood to read the article, but as I went on it seems that the essay became a little more angry than sad. He had a great transition from talking about a morose topic to the controversial gun control topic. He transitions by saying that after a tragic event no one wants to talk about the direct relation like a car crash and seatbelts. He then goes to sizing up the U.S to other countries. He uses many persuasive facts as well as eccentric emotion.
My opinion of Susan Sontag’s essay:
Unfortunately I have a differing opinion on Sontag’s essay. At the beginning she uses confusing word choice that throws me off the topic and has me running for a dictionary. That might just be me, but the mixture of easily understood and complicated vocabulary is key to any essay. Also the essay seems to attack the American government in a way that is somewhat unsettling. I am sure she was trying to make us uncomfortable, but it seems that my comfort zone was left miles behind when reading this essay. I don’t disagree with what she is saying. I agree that the government makes bias decisions, and rushed into the wars, but I don’t agree in her belittling our government. I think that she could’ve said it in a much nicer and comforting way, but I’m sure she was going for the hard slap in the face instead of a guided fall. Anyway the essay did get me thinking about what is kept from us by the government as was said in the third paragraph. Even if it were a little nerve wracking it did get me thinking about one of her points which is really all a good writer needs to do.
Thanks for the responses, Andrew. I found it interesting that you brought up the author's bias in both of the essays. This is a good thing to keep in mind when reading any text: what are the writer's unspoken goals and assumptions?
ReplyDeleteI personally like the stark image of the cell phones that Gopnik uses to start his essay, but he does run the risk of alienating the reader with such a strong opening.
Nice job keeping up with the posting. Keep reading and responding, and, if you haven't been, start reading and commenting on your classmates' blogs.
Is it quite shocking the numbers that the US has compared to other countries. Depressing even. What do you think we as a the public, as the government, could do about it? I think it's take the advice of the other countries. They seem to know what they are doing, but funny how it hurts us to know how blind we are. At least we stop being blind when our phones go unanswered and the ringing remains in our ears.
ReplyDeleteI like how you noted the writing styles of both authors in addition to the content of the essays. Now that I think about it, Gopnik's introduction alone definitely had me leaning towards his position. It's kind of funny how, even before stating his case, Gopnik can cause the reader to feel enough sympathy to lower their defense on the issue.
ReplyDelete"Gopnik never does talk about the other side and instead harasses the other sides faults in a somewhat bias manner, he brings up extremely valid points." I really like that you brought up the bias in the writing. It always helps when determining whether you side with the writer if they can mention the other side in a respectful manner, but not completely insult it.
ReplyDelete